C-level Team,
About a week ago we met with a consulting firm to figure out how we are going to move forward. We have heard some very interesting ideas and now are faced with some tough choices.We are facing the idea of being conservative and wait to be acquired, or move aggressively in all areas to attract and IPO.
When we were sitting and listening to the consultants they proposed two ideas that sparked an interest of mine. I liked the idea of an "Open Mic" channel that would generate revenue from independent artists that are not signed by major recording labels. The other idea is the "Sharing Community" where users can interact with Pandora and share with friends what they are listening to. This is a great way to keep the Pandora brand alive, however, this also seems short lived if not partnered with another online community that blogs.
I feel the consultants did a great job at allowing me to see additional value in Pandora. Providing new ideas that will enhance our brand as well as provide a revenue stream will keep the company moving forward with the times. With the implementation of the "Open Mic" and "Sharing Community" would be free advice and marketing from current users.
Let me know your thoughts!
Regards,
Tim Booker
Monday, June 24, 2013
Tuesday, June 18, 2013
Pandora Case Prep
Pandora Case Preparation
Problem
It all began in 1999 when Tim Westergren launched his
company, then titled Savage Beast, as a music discovery engine to connect
listeners with artists. The engine was dubbed as the Music Genome Project where
it required that each song placed in the library be dissected, first, by
analysts who spent approximately 20-30 minutes codifying as many as 400
different attributes to determine a song’s “musical DNA.” The DNA was used to
match a song to its “musical neighbor”, where users could find similar songs
that could create a particular mood. Initially this concept was sold to online
and offline music stores. The Music Genome served as the back-end to online
music experiences offered by America Online (AOL) and Barnes & Noble, in
addition to powering kiosks in offline record stores like Tower Records, Best
Buy, and Borders.
Due to the company’s economic situation, Westergren was
forced to devise a plan to keep the company afloat and complete the music
library to increase its value. In March 2004, Westergren was able to raise a
Series B round, second round financing for a business by private equity
investors or venture capitalists, led by Walden Venture Capital in San
Francisco. During this process, Westergren and the board decided that it would
be best to hire a new CEO. The new CEO, Joe Kennedy, proposed that that the
company change its strategy to become a direct-to-consumer Internet radio
service. It was then that Pandora.com was born. This provided a free, highly
customized online radio station powered by the Music Genome.
In December of 2007 found himself facing a similar issue
that he faced in 2004. Pandora.com user base has grown to 8 million, online
hours were growing 50% year on year, and although cash-flow has not reached a
positive level, trajectory reports indicate that it could reach a positive
cash-flow in two years. Westergren was grappling with satisfying the interest
of the investors while staying true to his own dreams for the company. The
choices he is faced with are: 1) Taking a more conservative path by reducing
the growth levers on SEM and general market spend, slow headcount growth, and
raise minimal amount of new investment to reach an exit through possible
acquisition? 2) Or, take an aggressive approach by topping out the SEM, hire
aggressively, and take advantage of the first-mover advantage? This would lead
to the company having the ability to raise a large round of financing to
command a heavy valuation to lead to a prospective IPO.
Situation Assessment
When Pandora was founded, the company used its capability to
provide back-end music recommendations to other companies. Shortly after the
Series B closing, the company also shifted its strategy to focus its efforts on
being a customizable Internet radio service. The service would give users the
ability to make preferential choices on types of music or artist and then match
those selections to songs in Pandora’s library and stream them to the user’s
PC.
In September 2005 launched its highly-customizable online
radio station and the following May Pandora had a user base of 6.5 million
registered users. In March 2007, the Copyright Royalty Board increased royalty
rates for Internet radio stations from $0.0117/hour to $.03/hour. Westegren
believe that rates like this would “kill” Internet radio sites including
Pandora.
Alternatives
Westergren was faced with two choices to decide from. His
choices are:
1) Taking a more conservative path by reducing the growth
levers on SEM and general market spend, slow headcount growth, and raise
minimal amount of new investment to reach an exit through possible acquisition?
2) Or, take an aggressive approach by topping out the SEM,
hire aggressively, and take advantage of the first-mover advantage? This would
lead to the company having the ability to raise a large round of financing to
command a heavy valuation to lead to a prospective IPO.
Recommendation
As the C-Level, I would consider option one as the path for
Pandora. As we see, technology is beginning to grow as the years progress. With
the music industry suffering from CD sales, having digital music will become
more common than going to purchase a CD. Shifting towards the ability to offer
users a download option would go completely against the business model that
Pandora has established. I would not discount radio, although it is becoming a
dying breed and listeners want more music versus talk radio. We need to be conservative
with our decisions that would keep us afloat until we can potential sell to a
reputable company that will utilize the music genome project in a capacity that
Pandora may never reach. Taking an aggressive stance would move Westergren away
from what he loves to do thus ultimately leading to a change in the business
model to compete with competitors. Granted this could lead to an IPO, but this
isn’t certain given how music is played and the source that it comes from.
Therefore, a conservative stance would drive Pandora to a possible acquisition
by another company to provide users a greater music experience.
Saturday, June 8, 2013
Bombardier Reflection
Executive Team,
I understand about a week ago you met with some consultants
about the third phase of the ERP. I also emailed over some suggestions of my
own but after reading the minutes from the meeting I found some points about
the presentation that I did not consider.
From the beginning I felt as though the presenting of a
phased roll-out would suit the company a great deal. The suggestions provided
by the consultants on focusing the attention to the core business functions
first would be best while giving them the ability to access legacy systems for
a limited period of time. Also making sure that the system is acceptable to end
users is key where we would not spend a lot of time figuring out a workaround.
Another point from their presentation that I agree with is
the training provided to the employees and how it is delivered. I believe that
job specific training will help in the development of the employee over time
with the new system. This would mean a total revamp of our training program for
the employees that will benefit us in the end.
Lastly is the tone from the top. Obviously here we are doing
well and should continue on our path. We need to let everyone know to accept
the new system and we are here to answer questions and make sure that everyone
is provided adequate training.
I hope we will use these best practices suggested by the
consultants as this would help us maximize the benefit of implementing this
ERP.
Regards,
TB
Bombardier Case
Bombardier Case
Preparation
Problem
After implementing
two installments of ERP previously, management is looking to improve the system
and learn from prior mistakes in order to have a more successful third ERP
implementation.
Following the
first ERP implementation, the outcome was lower than expected, so management
hired consultants for the second ERP implementation to explain best practices.
Although the results were better than following the first implementation, they
were not as successful as Bombardier had expected.
At this point,
problems have been identified by management that they are attempting to address
in order to maximize benefits of the ERP system. The limited success they have
had in the past is costing the company in resources. Ultimately Bombardier
would like to see its information sharing and data maintenance are kept in view
so the information flow is according to the company’s expectations.
Situation Assessment
According to
Frantz, Southerland and Johnson they compiled 16 best practices in which
companies should use a guide in implementing the best practices for ERP
systems. These are used to measure effectiveness and success of ERP
implementation.
The context of
this problem is that Bombardier Limited is a leading international manufacturer
of aerospace and transportation products with its aerospace division reporting
48.2 billion 2007. In an increasingly competitive aerospace manufacturing
industry, Bombardier recognized that it needed to transition its legacy
information systems towards an ERP system. Although technically a success
according to management due to its ability to reduce inventory by $1.2 billion
without jeopardizing operations or productions, the first rollout of ERP at the
Mirabel plant was extremely frustrating to users due to a large communication
gap between the project team and employees and the mismanagement of user input
and expectations by executives and the employees and the mismanagement of user
input and expectations by executives and the project team. The second rollout
was much smoother transition wise and employees were trained more adequately as
a result of a clear vision and unified message from senior management as to
what employee involvement and the priority placed on a company wide support of
the new system’s implementation. This third foray into ERP deployment should
build on the successes of Saint Laurent and improve on its failings by adhering
to ERP best practices.
Plausible
Alternatives
The alternative course of action would be to adopt the
best-of-best practices that lead to a positive ERP implementation. I would recommend
that Bombardier employ these best-of-best practices:
·
Executive management should endorse the ERP and
remain active throughout implementation. The importance and relevance of the
project will be reflected to employees as long as the “tone from the top” shows
acceptance. Support from the employees is critical for the success of the ERP
for all.
·
Assign a full-time Project Manager. With this
practice you can ensure that focus and attention is given at a high priority.
The dedicated employee would focus on the success of the rollout, gather
feedback, and work to resolve issues.
·
Training for employees before and after
implementation. The use of training throughout the implementation will ensure
that the system is understood and business needs are met. This would mean an
introduction to the new system and once implemented a more rigorous training
class on the new system. This allows the users to become familiar with the
system prior to classroom training. This was one of the major issues with the Mirabel
plant. Employees at the plant felt a disconnect with the implementation process
due to the training occurring at times prior to the event occurring. The result
showed that the employees could not recall training exercises which caused the
employees to feel “behind the pack” when the new system was launched. I would recommend
that Bombardier keep 1 or 2 people to stay on for an extended period of time to
provide additional support if need be.
·
Communication is key. Here Bombardier needs to
be transparent with the flow of information to the users. This will establish a
sense of trust between the business community and the project team.
Recommendation
I would suggest using all of these best practices listed in
combination. Being mindful of the prior phases, Bombardier should reflect on
those lessons. Bombardier should be able to establish a new foundation and
strive for on-going communication and involvement to gain maximization of
benefits.
Wednesday, May 29, 2013
Ubuntu Tech Tool
Dear IT Team,
I am writing to you to bring forth an OS that I was reviewing online. The name of the OS is called Ubuntu. I know we currently use Windows as our operating system but what caught my attention was the similarities between both OS in terms of productivity suites.
For starters this is an Linux based platform, open source OS where Ubuntu, which is backed by Canonical, has volunteers who help build and keep Ubuntu running with the most up to date productivity suites. To give a background on Canonical, it is a partnership with Ubuntu where Canonical is responsible for delivering six-monthly releases, as well as co-ordinating security, trouble-shooting and providing an online platform for community interaction. Canonical works closely with businesses and individuals alike. Canonical also develops bespoke systems, provides comprehensive support and all the training that’s necessary to get everybody up and running. With more than 500 employees in over 18 countries, the company continues expanding to support the millions of Ubuntu users around the world.
Now that you have a foundation of Ubuntu and it's partnership with Canonical lets dive straight in to the productivity suite and its compatibility with Microsoft Office. From what I have tested on my own and read, the Libreoffice suite opens and allows me to edit my word and excel files with ease. It's almost like a seamless transition between the two OS office suites.
Considering using the Ubuntu OS system in our organization would be far fetched. Granted there would be tremendous cost savings but there are some many unanswered questions as will the software we currently use work with the Linux platform. Also considering the many access databases we have organized to pull data from other sources, a major overhaul of our OS to this magnitude would be costly in the realm training, implementation, and possible restructuring of our databases. Considering these factors, I do not believe this will be the best decision for our organization at this time. The savings do not outweigh the cost of having this OS.
Feel free to test Ubuntu yourself and let me know your thoughts.
Regards,
Timothy Booker
Tuesday, May 21, 2013
iPad Case
Dear Newsbelkis,
I have researched the usage of Apple iPads for the Amrahp
employees that are in the sales force. After speaking with the Head of IT,
Sales Manager, and the VP of Finance, I compiled a list of concerns and
gathered as much information I could find to present to you. The goal I believe
that is trying to be accomplished is meeting the functional and technical
requirements we have set.
The biggest concern that I found was the ability to safe
guard our information. Apple has built these devices with standardized
configurations that provide security. However, given the sensitive nature of
the information we possess, we will need multiple layers of security. Some of
the features we can utilize such as remote wipe if the device is stolen or
lost, mobile device management, and digital certificates.
Since the device is primarily application based, appropriate
apps must be either built or purchased to mirror what is used on the laptop.
There are several third party vendors that are compatible with our Microsoft
Office Suite or we can build our own app using Apple iOS Developer Enterprise
Program tools. To gain access we will need to register each developer for the
site and pay $299/year for the service. The good thing is we can build, test,
and deploy the app using this tool. Here we can create an address book,
calendar, task list, and much more specific to the user; sort of like an
electronic briefcase.
I do not foresee this project being a burden on the company,
however the initial costs and time to get the sales team established will be
the biggest hurdle. Most of the information was readily accessible through www.apple.com/business. Check it out
when you get a chance.
Regards,
Timothy Booker
Monday, May 20, 2013
ZARA Reflection
Dear Mr. Salgado and Mr. Sanchez,
Recently you met with Fast Solution Consultant in regards to our current POS system. I understand we were presented with three options, upgrading infrastructure and Operating System, Porting existing POS application to new OS, and Not changing existing system. When conducting my analysis I found that upgrading our current infrastructure and OS would prepare us for the changes in technology as well as provide us the accessibility needed to serve our customers. The cost is a bit expensive at first, but the initial costs will end and we will be left with our annual cost However, the benefit of us making this move will give us access to our inventory allowing us to find the right product for our customers. We are still keeping our boutique feel and structure but we are also enhancing our services to benefit our customers.
Hopefully the presentation from Fast Solution Consultants help solidify the recommendation that I made prior.
Regards,
Timothy Booker
Recently you met with Fast Solution Consultant in regards to our current POS system. I understand we were presented with three options, upgrading infrastructure and Operating System, Porting existing POS application to new OS, and Not changing existing system. When conducting my analysis I found that upgrading our current infrastructure and OS would prepare us for the changes in technology as well as provide us the accessibility needed to serve our customers. The cost is a bit expensive at first, but the initial costs will end and we will be left with our annual cost However, the benefit of us making this move will give us access to our inventory allowing us to find the right product for our customers. We are still keeping our boutique feel and structure but we are also enhancing our services to benefit our customers.
Hopefully the presentation from Fast Solution Consultants help solidify the recommendation that I made prior.
Regards,
Timothy Booker
Accenture Reflection
Dear Mr. Modruson,
A few days ago you met with a Prestige Consulting to determine our IT strategy and found that the topic if concern, or possible plain, is moving towards COBIT 5. I understand that we have implemented a massive overhaul of our IT system to go towards a single vendor. A strong point that was mentioned in the presentation was the usage of COBIT 5 for a financial gain. As this is a smart move for financial reasons, have we determined the number of clients who will benefit from this service? Have the consultants considered any potential setbacks or constraints if we decided to move towards COBIT 5? The process that is in place works well as it has been developed by you and your team, so you can spot a bottleneck in the process versus adapting to a new framework. In the end there are still some questions to be answered and the use of visual aid of our current process compared to the proposed framework could show more information.
The accreditation of COBIT 5 involves standards being put in place that will not allow for deviation. This would involve a commitment from the several departments and giving up the freedom that is in place now. I would suggest we should consider all the options prior to moving forward with this framework.
Regards,
Timothy Booker
A few days ago you met with a Prestige Consulting to determine our IT strategy and found that the topic if concern, or possible plain, is moving towards COBIT 5. I understand that we have implemented a massive overhaul of our IT system to go towards a single vendor. A strong point that was mentioned in the presentation was the usage of COBIT 5 for a financial gain. As this is a smart move for financial reasons, have we determined the number of clients who will benefit from this service? Have the consultants considered any potential setbacks or constraints if we decided to move towards COBIT 5? The process that is in place works well as it has been developed by you and your team, so you can spot a bottleneck in the process versus adapting to a new framework. In the end there are still some questions to be answered and the use of visual aid of our current process compared to the proposed framework could show more information.
The accreditation of COBIT 5 involves standards being put in place that will not allow for deviation. This would involve a commitment from the several departments and giving up the freedom that is in place now. I would suggest we should consider all the options prior to moving forward with this framework.
Regards,
Timothy Booker
Friday, May 17, 2013
Accenture Case
Problem:
After the split between Andersen Consulting and Arthur
Andersen, Andersen consulting spent millions on a rebranding campaign to build
awareness of Accenture being the world’s largest management consulting firm.
With the split and the need to unify themselves, Accenture needed to make
substantial advancements in their IT department. They needed to run this
department as a business to control costs and the inconsistencies in software
at the different location. Accenture faced a dated IT infrastructure that was
made up of platforms that are obsolete and did not communicate seamlessly with
one another. This also made remote access very difficult and costly to set up.
Information was compiled and manually uploaded to aggregate results from
offices. Offices in other locations began adopting their own software to run a
business. The problem that Accenture is having is not from the data infrastructure,
but from the governance with IT and future projects will be handled.
Situation Assessment:
Accenture has completed a holistic overhaul of their IT
infrastructure allowing the business to run its IT like a business within
Accenture. In doing so Accenture decided to go with a single vendor approach
providing one system for all users and meeting the application needs through
economies of scale. The overhaul introduced a newly formed steering committee
that included high-level management and senior IT staff to define the IT horizon
for the coming fiscal year as well as updating the strategic direction of IT
for the next three years.
COBIT 5 framework is designed to help enterprises of all
sizes. The framework addresses business and IT functional areas across an enterprise
and considers the IT-related interest of internal and external stakeholders.
The framework is based upon five key principles: Meeting Stakeholders Needs,
Covering the Enterprises End to End, Applying a single, integrated framework, Enabling
a holistic approach, and Separating Governance from Management. The benefits of
using the framework is to maintain high-quality information to support business
decisions, achieve strategic goals and realize business benefits through the
effective and innovative use of IT, achieve operational excellence through
reliable, efficient application of technology, maintain IT-related risk at an
acceptable level, optimize the cost of IT services and technology, and support
compliance with relevant laws, regulations, contractual agreements and
policies.
Alternatives:
Accenture is debating between using their own IT governance
or purchasing the service from the Information Systems Audit and Control
Association (ISACA).
The benefits of creating your own steering committee is the
ability to collective create new rules, be a part of new product offerings or
process changes. This will also keep the business sponsor and IT team alert due
to the audits to determine ROI and that the project is managed effectively. The
cons to establishing your own steering committee is the pushback from the
different managers. Managers will provide excuses as to why presenting to the
steering committee their projects will not work.
The alternative to creating a steering committee is
purchasing licenses from the Information Systems Audit and Control Association
(ISACA). Here Accenture would be purchasing a framework built upon other major
frameworks, standards and resources such as ISACA’s Val IT and Risk IT,
Information Technology Infrastructure Library, and standards from the
International Organization for Standardization (ISO). Adopting the COBIT 5
framework would require some changes in separation of governance and
management. Also there are the training courses that would give users a full
understanding of the framework. The courses can be taught globally with its
main locations in the United States and England.
Recommendation:
I would recommend against adopting the COBIT 5 framework for
Accenture to use. This would call for further disruption to implement as well
as Accenture losing its identity upon what it has already built. The framework
is a generalized set of standards that can be applied to any business. The basic
principles and enablers are similar to the framework that has been established
by Accenture steering committee. With the current process in place, Accenture
has reduced spending per employee by 60% and reduced IT’s overall expenses as a
percentage of net revenue by 58%. The process works as it is currently set up
when Accenture reviewed its company as workforce doubled in size from 2001 to
2008.
ZARA Case
Background:
Zara is a clothing retail store for
women, men and children, concentrating sixty percent of their effort to the
women’s clothing market. Besides retailing, Zara also designs, produces, and
ships their lines of clothing to their Zara stores. Zara’s corporate concept is
to offer fashionable, trendy, designs at a reasonable price. The key to
their corporate success is to offer the latest trends and fashions before their
competitors (H&M, Gap, and Benetton). They believe that they are in
the fashion business (not the clothing business per se) and as part of this
corporate concept, try to hold very low levels of inventory, often having their
entire inventory out on display, in order to sell out and make room for the
next wave of fashion. Zara started out in 1979 with 6 stores and flourished to
all major Spanish cities during the 1980′s. Within the next decade,
Zara’s parent company, Inditex, expanded to 29 countries across Europe, the
Americas, and Asia. Additionally, during this time Index acquired other
big name fashion brands; each
operating independently of each other. By 2002, Index had expanded to 1,284 stores in 39 countries. Zara represents 75% of Inditex sales, and by 2003 Zara had 565 stores in 33 countries. Zara examined its IT infrastructure and determined that it may be beneficial to consider implementing a new upgraded POS system to create a more robust system that is responsive to Inditex’s supply chain network and also to remove the risk it currently is facing with the existing system becoming obsolete as their vendors move on to other systems that may no longer be DOS compatible.
operating independently of each other. By 2002, Index had expanded to 1,284 stores in 39 countries. Zara represents 75% of Inditex sales, and by 2003 Zara had 565 stores in 33 countries. Zara examined its IT infrastructure and determined that it may be beneficial to consider implementing a new upgraded POS system to create a more robust system that is responsive to Inditex’s supply chain network and also to remove the risk it currently is facing with the existing system becoming obsolete as their vendors move on to other systems that may no longer be DOS compatible.
Problem:
The problem in this case stems from a conversation between
Salgado, the Head of IT for Inditex, and Sanchez, the technical leader for
Zara’s POS System. Zara currently uses a Point of Sale system to run their
business. Salgado thinks an upgraded system is necessary to remain competitive
in terms of technology and the upgrades their hardware vendor is making which
would no longer be DOS compatible. Sanchez thinks there is more risk involved
in upgrading the system since it works just fine and has proven to be stable –
he has the mind set of if it’s not broken don’t fix it. Sanchez also knows all
of the ins and outs of the system and believes he can handle any issues that
they face with it – both currently and in the future. Overall, the main problem
Zara is facing is if they should or should not upgrade their system.
Situation Assessment:
Zara’s business model puts a great emphasis on speed and decentralized decision-making. They have no Chief Information Officer and follow no formal process when deciding on an IT budget or new IT projects. Zara employs a technology committee that Salgado and Sanchez both take part in. When this concern was raised in the past, the committee decided that it was best to write the applications required for the programs themselves in order to apply the unique concepts required by Zara. They were against purchasing commercially available software because of the uniqueness of their brand. The only commercial applications used are ones such as word processing and emails to ensure office productivity. Such applications that run the heart of the business include applications created to prepare offers and distribute it over the Internet to stores internationally and to receive orders from those stores, applications created to compare aggregate orders to available inventory for each SKU, and applications created to track “theoretical inventory” in which shipments increase it and sales decrease it.
Another form of technology currently used by Zara are PDAs, which require POS terminals. PDA’s are used in-store by employees to order inventory, handle returns, and transmit information to other stores. Store managers and salespeople must initially determine necessary orders by counting garments as they walk around the store and communicate with one another. Inventory balances cannot be looked up on any in-store computers. Managers learn about new available garments through their PDA by linking it at the end of each day through a dial-up modem connecting it to an information system in La Coruna. When managing a new store opening, employees must insert new floppy drives into a blank POS terminal. Both the POS terminals and the PDAs are not always connected to headquarters or other stores; therefore, employees must copy daily sales totals from each terminal to floppy disks, carry the disk to the modem-equipped terminal, and complete the transition. POS terminals are a huge part of Zara’s business model and day-to-day functions, but Salgado and Sanchez both have valid concerns regarding the future of them. On one hand, if the hardware vendor does actually change its machines, Zara will be left without a system. The vendor has stated that Zara is his only customer using a more dated system. On the other hand, a new technology might prove to be overkill for the type of business Zara is running and in turn destabilize Zara’s easy and efficient existing system.
Zara’s business model puts a great emphasis on speed and decentralized decision-making. They have no Chief Information Officer and follow no formal process when deciding on an IT budget or new IT projects. Zara employs a technology committee that Salgado and Sanchez both take part in. When this concern was raised in the past, the committee decided that it was best to write the applications required for the programs themselves in order to apply the unique concepts required by Zara. They were against purchasing commercially available software because of the uniqueness of their brand. The only commercial applications used are ones such as word processing and emails to ensure office productivity. Such applications that run the heart of the business include applications created to prepare offers and distribute it over the Internet to stores internationally and to receive orders from those stores, applications created to compare aggregate orders to available inventory for each SKU, and applications created to track “theoretical inventory” in which shipments increase it and sales decrease it.
Another form of technology currently used by Zara are PDAs, which require POS terminals. PDA’s are used in-store by employees to order inventory, handle returns, and transmit information to other stores. Store managers and salespeople must initially determine necessary orders by counting garments as they walk around the store and communicate with one another. Inventory balances cannot be looked up on any in-store computers. Managers learn about new available garments through their PDA by linking it at the end of each day through a dial-up modem connecting it to an information system in La Coruna. When managing a new store opening, employees must insert new floppy drives into a blank POS terminal. Both the POS terminals and the PDAs are not always connected to headquarters or other stores; therefore, employees must copy daily sales totals from each terminal to floppy disks, carry the disk to the modem-equipped terminal, and complete the transition. POS terminals are a huge part of Zara’s business model and day-to-day functions, but Salgado and Sanchez both have valid concerns regarding the future of them. On one hand, if the hardware vendor does actually change its machines, Zara will be left without a system. The vendor has stated that Zara is his only customer using a more dated system. On the other hand, a new technology might prove to be overkill for the type of business Zara is running and in turn destabilize Zara’s easy and efficient existing system.
Alternatives:
1. Do not change the system
One alternative as suggested by Sanchez is for Zara to leave the
system as is. Zara has been able to run a successful, efficient, and productive
business on POS terminals. The system has proven to be stable by running
without many complications. Employees have also been able to use the system without
additional IT service. By 2003, Inditex has opened 550 Zara stores
internationally, with Zara accounting for a majority of its sales, all while
operating on POS terminals. Any shift away from this system might prove to be
an unnecessary risk, affecting the entire flow of the company. While keeping
the same system, Zara can choose to purchase more POS terminals. Doing this
would provide a safety-net for the company if they happen to lose the support
of their vendor. Although the vendor has shown no desire to change the
machines, being that Zara is its only customer using this system, they cannot
be sure a change will not occur in the near future.
2. Update POS to another system
The other alternative would be to completely update POS to
another system such as Windows, UNIX, or Linux. This option would require a
complete change to the company. Such a change would allow for new capabilities
such as larger screens, keyboards, and mouse attachments, along with wireless
networks. The new capabilities would satisfy some employee complaints and
wireless networks would eliminate the need for floppy disks and allow for
permanent Internet connection. The addition of wireless networks will also keep
all stores connected to headquarters and allow for a quicker way to know all
inventories. To upgrade their system Zara is looking at a significant cost for
implementation and training. Being that Zara does not usually allocate a formal
budget toward IT investments, this cost might appear high. Although significant
costs might be incurred, Zara will no longer have to work with the POS vendor
and can let go of the uncertainty that he might change his machines and leave
them without an operating system at some point in the future (whether sooner or
later). This option also allows Zara to remain technologically competitive as
advances continue to occur and competitors advance along as well. This ensures
Zara will not fall behind in efficiency and lose customers or momentum as a
result.
Recommendation:
This case provides a difficult set of
alternatives to choose from. Deciding to leave the system as is might save Zara
from incurring costs now, but it might prove to be a more costly decision in
the future. On the other hand, upgrading their system now will require a
significant investment, but may prevent significant costs in the future. I
recommend that Zara upgrade their system. It is clear that technology is advancing
quickly and although their system works fine now, it will not benefit them to
remain with this same process as the end all. The familiarity of their current
process will only keep them stable and efficient for the time being. At some
point it will become even more outdated than it already is, forcing Zara to
upgrade anyway. Upgrading to a new operating system now will allow them to
prepare more adequately in order to handle the changes to come with the new
process.
Microsoft Visio
Dr. P,
I would like to comment on the usage of Visio and how this software could bring value to our department. I found the product to be easy to use and a great tool to describe a current work process or to be used when trying to shift to a new work process. This tool can even be used when training new employees, providing a visual aid to illustrate the workflow.
Another great feature I notice with the software is the ability to create an organizational chart. Here we can show the reporting structure of the company to vendors, new hires, and even current employees. The best part about this product is that we can even construct a floor plan to have an idea of where each employee is seated within the building. There are several templates available to suit the needs of the task at hand.
I have found that we can purchase individual licenses and push them out to each workstation where the this tool will be used.
Please provide me your thoughts as I will work with IT to gather a completion time.
Thanks,
TB
I would like to comment on the usage of Visio and how this software could bring value to our department. I found the product to be easy to use and a great tool to describe a current work process or to be used when trying to shift to a new work process. This tool can even be used when training new employees, providing a visual aid to illustrate the workflow.
Another great feature I notice with the software is the ability to create an organizational chart. Here we can show the reporting structure of the company to vendors, new hires, and even current employees. The best part about this product is that we can even construct a floor plan to have an idea of where each employee is seated within the building. There are several templates available to suit the needs of the task at hand.
I have found that we can purchase individual licenses and push them out to each workstation where the this tool will be used.
Please provide me your thoughts as I will work with IT to gather a completion time.
Thanks,
TB
Thursday, May 9, 2013
Proctor and Gamble
Problem/Issue Statement:
Proctor & Gamble is experiencing a longer wait time versus its competitors when trying to reduce the time is takes for clinical trials in its pharmaceutical division to be completed and bring new products to the market. The current process involves using data collection that is paper based where the first portion of information is collected on site by the coordinator, then this information is verified by the clinical research associate, and then this is manually inputted into P&G’s database by the clinical data manager.
The problem is found in the data collection process that is lengthy and involves multiple parties that are duplicating work. This involves the aforementioned parties collecting the data on site, then passing the same information to be verified by the clinical research associate before it is entered in to the P&G database. These steps are the cause of increasing lag times in sending/receiving the data by paper versus utilizing the internet to take advantage of Electronic Data Capture (EDC).
Situation Assessment:
The situation with P&G is their need to decrease the time between the trail and bringing the drug to shelves. The process that is in place currently involves a great deal of paper being transferred by hand which is causing for the trial to last longer and decreasing profits. The goal of the consultants is to assess the alternatives to find the most effective and efficient way to streamline the process and increase profits for P&G.
List of Plausible Alternative Courses of Action:
Three alternatives were presented of consideration involving P&G current process. The alternatives are improving the paper-based process, Web-enabled EDC, or Digital Imaging.
Improving the paper-based process would involve using express mail shipments on a daily basis as well as hiring additional staffing to speed up the verification process.
Web-enabled EDC is the toughest out of the three options to implement. The reason behind that statement is due to the amount of training involved to bring all the employees up to speed on how the system works and make sure that the level of training provides enough knowledge to access the program. In addition to the training, the facilities that P&G operates these trials from will need to have their systems updated and provide system access with various degrees of access to its employees.
Digital Imaging is the ability to take the completed paper documents and transfer the information via fax to receive the information in a digital format and save to the system. The limitation with this option is the level of training that needs to be administered to the employees.
Logical Recommendation:
The logical recommendation would be the web-enabled EDC. This new process will decrease the amount of time it takes for the information to be inputted in to the system. With this new system, patient data is keyed into the system allowing for the transmission of the data to be instantly available. However, for the convenience of the system would require P&G to spend more in initial cost and training. But in the long run, this process would show greater efficiency and ultimately pay for itself once new products are able to make its way to market quicker.
Presentation:
The focus of the presentation should be on the ineffectiveness of the current process. This should be illustrated by using flow charts and showing where the lag occurs. Once this has been identified my team and I would then propose the solution we would choose. We wouldn’t necessarily discuss the alternative as Digital Imaging does not stand up to Web-enabled EDC. With the solution proposal we would discuss the ease of use and how the employees will adapt seamlessly with the new process with the training that is provided. Here would be a good time for the team to talk about how the information is secured to address any uncertainties with the system. Finally we would conclude the presentation with the cost savings over time when using EDC and how profits increase per drug by the decreased time in processing information during the trial and getting the drug on the shelves.
Reflection:
After hearing the consultants present their case to P&G, I found that we both agree that EDC is the best option overall. The group provided an in-depth overview of the process demonstrating their understanding of P&G and their pharmaceutical division. The group did explain each alternative spending the majority of time touching on EDC and its benefits. Another good point I noticed with the group is the explanation on savings with each alternative which illustrates from a dollar perspective which would be a contender for the new process. In the end I feel the consultants provided a quality presentation to propose a solution to P&G.
Friday, April 26, 2013
Impact of Blogging
Web Logging or Blogging as it is called today is the electronic form of journaling. I remember as a child in grade school we were to keep journals in our English class to document our experiences or thoughts day to day. Now what was once a simple assignment has now evolved in to a media outlet where any one can write or comment about their thoughts and feelings for the world to see.
When you think about it and know that someone is reading your words and thoughts, it's amazing and also a little weird. But this is life as we know it! People blog to voice their feelings or concerns and allow others to share in their passion. To a degree words have power if you are compelling enough to write a moving speech about equal rights or laws.
This simple yet effective and large forum allows my voice as well as others to be heard where if I wanted to gather some people to rally and spark a change I have a free stage to do it. I can reach people across the world just by clicking "publish" and in an instant my message has gone viral. Not to mention the ability to use this forum to help those in need of encouragement providing kind words or expressions to uplift someone's spirits.
Blogging has made such an impact on society that people and even companies use it, but just under 140 characters. Here I am referencing Twitter an the new fascination Instagram. Although Instagram is just reaching being mainstream and involves photos being snapped at the time, Twitter has become the accepted medium of the two. Companies and individuals use Twitter to advertise, promote, report, and comment on various subject matters. Depending on your usage, like Blogger, people can "follow" you to see what new comments you will make. If you are intriguing and sort of a big deal, people will hang on your every word waiting for the next post.
Bringing it back to the impact of blogging, this medium allows us to express ourselves freely with no reservations. We can say what we want, how we want due to freedom of speech. With this platform we stand on we can either spark change or create controversy. The choice is up to the writer and what he/she publishes.
When you think about it and know that someone is reading your words and thoughts, it's amazing and also a little weird. But this is life as we know it! People blog to voice their feelings or concerns and allow others to share in their passion. To a degree words have power if you are compelling enough to write a moving speech about equal rights or laws.
This simple yet effective and large forum allows my voice as well as others to be heard where if I wanted to gather some people to rally and spark a change I have a free stage to do it. I can reach people across the world just by clicking "publish" and in an instant my message has gone viral. Not to mention the ability to use this forum to help those in need of encouragement providing kind words or expressions to uplift someone's spirits.
Blogging has made such an impact on society that people and even companies use it, but just under 140 characters. Here I am referencing Twitter an the new fascination Instagram. Although Instagram is just reaching being mainstream and involves photos being snapped at the time, Twitter has become the accepted medium of the two. Companies and individuals use Twitter to advertise, promote, report, and comment on various subject matters. Depending on your usage, like Blogger, people can "follow" you to see what new comments you will make. If you are intriguing and sort of a big deal, people will hang on your every word waiting for the next post.
Bringing it back to the impact of blogging, this medium allows us to express ourselves freely with no reservations. We can say what we want, how we want due to freedom of speech. With this platform we stand on we can either spark change or create controversy. The choice is up to the writer and what he/she publishes.
Google Drive or something else?
Google Drive doesn't mean you can use it in your car and expect to reach your destination. Yet it is a platform designed to allow users the ability to store and share documents with other users of their choice. One would say it is a form of cloud computing given the ability to access the documents anywhere there is Internet access. I would agree!
I began using the platform to test out its effectiveness and see if it could be used as an alternative for personal use compared to my external hard drive with cloud capabilities. I would like to have performed this comparison for my employer but given my line of work, security plays a major role and I can't say Google Drive is secure enough. So the comparison would be my own cloud on my network or Google Drive?
From my experience Google Drive shares some of same functionalities as other cloud platforms. The accessibility, storage, sharing, plus it's backed by Google. However a major flaw that I found to be counterproductive is the sharing of a document with editing capabilities that could occur simultaneously in real-time. Some would find that feature as being fantastic, I found it to be a headache. I couldn't tell if I were making a change or if the other user was. The program should remain simple where you upload and share or download. Plus for more storage space there is a fee.
With my own cloud, I purchased an external hard drive that allows me to access it via the Internet. So with any computer that has Internet I can access my storage, for free, any where I like. It does the same thing as any other cloud storage that is available except it's on my network. Therefore I own an control the documents and storage.
So which to choose, I would say it's a matter of preference. I prefer my external hard due to the fact of me owning the storage and knowing only my family can access it. It's password protected an provides an app to access the drive while on the go. Sharing documents is just as easy if not easier using my own personal storage versus Internet based.
I began using the platform to test out its effectiveness and see if it could be used as an alternative for personal use compared to my external hard drive with cloud capabilities. I would like to have performed this comparison for my employer but given my line of work, security plays a major role and I can't say Google Drive is secure enough. So the comparison would be my own cloud on my network or Google Drive?
From my experience Google Drive shares some of same functionalities as other cloud platforms. The accessibility, storage, sharing, plus it's backed by Google. However a major flaw that I found to be counterproductive is the sharing of a document with editing capabilities that could occur simultaneously in real-time. Some would find that feature as being fantastic, I found it to be a headache. I couldn't tell if I were making a change or if the other user was. The program should remain simple where you upload and share or download. Plus for more storage space there is a fee.
With my own cloud, I purchased an external hard drive that allows me to access it via the Internet. So with any computer that has Internet I can access my storage, for free, any where I like. It does the same thing as any other cloud storage that is available except it's on my network. Therefore I own an control the documents and storage.
So which to choose, I would say it's a matter of preference. I prefer my external hard due to the fact of me owning the storage and knowing only my family can access it. It's password protected an provides an app to access the drive while on the go. Sharing documents is just as easy if not easier using my own personal storage versus Internet based.
Sunday, April 14, 2013
So many choices....now down to two
The blog title speaks for itself. This is my first blog ever, on blogger that is, but blogging isn't any different from keeping a journal. Except with this funky concept that Google provides us we can now share our thoughts with whomever. However, this blog is not about the history or the root of blogging. My first blog is about my quest to buy a camera. I am by no means a photographer or even an aspiring photographer. I just like to take tons of photos but am looking for the best camera to do it with.
Now I have been looking at cameras for almost a year. This all started when I got married an saw how outstanding my photos came out. Granted, my wife and I (I love you sweetie! Yes I'm madly in love with my wife) hired a professional photographer to capture that wonderful day, I thought after seeing the photos and said "hey I can take photos like that!" So I sat out on my quest to find a camera that would give me the best pictures. Since my wife and I are travelers and outdoors people, I coupled are activities and used it as more of a reason to buy a camera.
So after countless searching I ended up narrowing my choices down to two brands. Before I go further, I just want to add how expensive this hobby is and this greatly influenced my decision. I didn't want just your simple "point and shoot" but I wanted interchangeable lenses and so forth. After seeing the cost of lenses I knew that I was ONLY buying one lens and that was all. Another factor was the size. Since I did my homework, I knew that the censor size matters for the clarity in pictures. Also the better the picture the more space it uses on my PC. But again, I'm not looking to be a professional, I just want good photos.
The choices I narrowed it down to are a Sony NEX-6 or a Canon T3i. Both are priced relatively the same, however, the Sony camera is smaller. The choice is not an easy one as Canon is know for its cameras. And Sony is best known for PlayStation. This process has been going on for a year and with hopes I will purchase one. I first must overcome the fact that technology changes like the season and what may be dated to the times now, the same product will be outdated within 6 months. In the end I have no new camera yet, but a formidable replacement has been my iPad.
Who needs a camera when you have an iPad?
Now I have been looking at cameras for almost a year. This all started when I got married an saw how outstanding my photos came out. Granted, my wife and I (I love you sweetie! Yes I'm madly in love with my wife) hired a professional photographer to capture that wonderful day, I thought after seeing the photos and said "hey I can take photos like that!" So I sat out on my quest to find a camera that would give me the best pictures. Since my wife and I are travelers and outdoors people, I coupled are activities and used it as more of a reason to buy a camera.
So after countless searching I ended up narrowing my choices down to two brands. Before I go further, I just want to add how expensive this hobby is and this greatly influenced my decision. I didn't want just your simple "point and shoot" but I wanted interchangeable lenses and so forth. After seeing the cost of lenses I knew that I was ONLY buying one lens and that was all. Another factor was the size. Since I did my homework, I knew that the censor size matters for the clarity in pictures. Also the better the picture the more space it uses on my PC. But again, I'm not looking to be a professional, I just want good photos.
The choices I narrowed it down to are a Sony NEX-6 or a Canon T3i. Both are priced relatively the same, however, the Sony camera is smaller. The choice is not an easy one as Canon is know for its cameras. And Sony is best known for PlayStation. This process has been going on for a year and with hopes I will purchase one. I first must overcome the fact that technology changes like the season and what may be dated to the times now, the same product will be outdated within 6 months. In the end I have no new camera yet, but a formidable replacement has been my iPad.
Who needs a camera when you have an iPad?
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)